Vigano situation: Who’s the real writer of the newest blog site out of Archbishop Vigano ?

Author Name(s):
Author Email:

Vigano situation: Who’s the real writer of the newest blog site out of Archbishop Vigano ?

I have used a comprehensive studies of the similarities of style and you can blogs between Baronio’s texts and people we will today ascribe so you can Vigano II, to recognize such website from 2020-2021 on very different of these away from Vigano We, of the ages 2018-2019

(Emmanuele Barbieri-Roberto de Mattei) That is the genuine composer of the brand new web log of Archbishop Carlo ? Let us try to promote a solution to practical question that we raised in the Corrispondenza Romana ( here ), beginning with a yes method: the study and you can review of your own site for the texts out-of most other people traceable on the internet. Just what for the scientific jargon is known as stylometric look.

Well then, the analysis from lexical and stylistic elements guides us to just you to you’ll writer: “Cesare Baronio,” otherwise “Baronius,” journalist and you will journalist, out of 2010 to help you 2020, of one’s blog lavalife site Opportune Importune.

Prominent so you can Baronio and you will Vigano II is the app to progressives of the terms “counter-church,”, “conciliar sect” ( right here this is how ) or “innovators” ( here that is where ).

Vatican Council II try a couple of times laid out by the one another once the a keen “idol.” To have Baronio, up to “the fresh conciliar idol try overthrown, using the let down recollections of its architects, it would be impractical to punish brand new high priests who’ve besieged Rome to possess fifty years” (, here ). Vigano II, within his latest Interview with the Liturgy, along with talks of Vatican II due to the fact an idol and, eg Baronio, establishes a beneficial Vatican II-Novus Ordo Missae equivalence.

” Vigano II writes one to “the fresh new architects of these liturgy” was basically “prelates will guessed from belonging to Freemasonry, notoriously modern” ( here ) ; Baronio therefore speaks out of “an excellent rite composed because of the infamously modern and you can Masonic prelates” (, right here ).

The newest instructions of the the brand new liturgy in order to Baronio was “published missals whose setting are that of a good plotline to refer to help you to own versions on some national dialects” (, here ). To own Vigano II, these types of liturgical books “is actually developed since a plan, an excellent plotline at the mercy of basically talented stars in search of social applause” ( right here ).

To possess Baronio “the latest offertory disappears entirely and make means for good Jewish prayer which have a great pantheistic preferences” (, here ); Vigano II talks of which prayer once the “Talmudic offertory” ( right here ).

Baronio and you may Vigano II, whenever discussing the newest Novus Ordo regarding Paul VI, constantly speak of the “reformed rite” or “Montinian rite

According to Vigano “the very-entitled ‘Blonde chasuble’ throughout the variations one preceded the fresh Council, particularly in France, is that kind of poncho hence pursuing the Council was enacted out-of into the us since the a recuperation of brand spanking new setting,” but is “a historical including liturgical fake” ( here ). Baronio composed you to: “the brand new conciliar chasuble are a beneficial horrid poncho that nothing to create on planeta explained from the Saint Charles Borromeo (Instructionum fabricae, 1557), and therefore we find depicted in many frescoes, images, miniatures and you will enamels given that Old” (, here ).

Vigano denounces “attempts to improve reformed liturgy presentable that have fairly inadequate functions away from maquillage” ( here ). Baronio produces you to definitely “operations regarding routine maquillage towards the Novus Ordo can be found in our have a look at destined throughout the greater part of circumstances for the most miserable shipwreck” (, right here ).

One can possibly embark on forever, but what things extremely outside of the spoken coincidences is the same tone, and therefore conveys a good smug liturgical, theological, and you can historic knowledge that Baronio provides flaunted for a decade to your their blog site but is totally missing on the 24 months from public statements by Vigano I.

127 total views, no views today

About the author: dev